In case you have not been reading this site, Google used to show us all the links pointing to our sites. Just prior to 1 July 2010, they restricted the available metrics to only a small "sample" set of links. For some of our clients, this sample is less than 0.1% of their total links. A very deceptive link labeled "Download all external links" still sits at the bottom of the inbound links list, but this will only get you the sample list, not all external links.
Go take a look and see how your site is handled. Most large commerce sites will have pretty big numbers - 100,000 links is very common. If you have those kinds of numbers, then you're probably going to be disappointed to see the size of the 'sample' available to you in WMT.
We're working on alternatives, but really there are none that will tell us what Google is crediting our sites with. Many external tools, like seomoz, Yahoo linkdomain searches, etc. will show you a set of inbound links, so getting a list is not the problem. The issue is that if you're trying to run forensics on a rank problem in Google, you want to discover what Google is crediting you with, not all the links pointing at your site. This is especially important since Google never indexes or credits ALL the links, so being able to see the specific sources is what matters.
My question to Webmaster Central within Google forums has not been answered: Is the removal of inbound link metrics from WMT a permanent degradation of that tool? This leads me to suspect it's gone for good and that so few people care that there will be no pushback.
More on coping later.
I interpret no answer from Google to mean that this is not going to revert to the previous state. These metrics are lost to us if no one else pushes back, and it looks like no one else is going to. Did you contact the other top seos to see if they would discuss this disaster in their forums?
Contacted all the big names, including Bruce Clay, Danny Sullivan, Aaron Wall, etc. Only Danny Sullivan replied (via a proxy) and suggested (erroneously) that they may have already covered the topic in their blog. Have not seen a single post outside of re1y.com. I guess the big retail seos don't handle problems.
re1y.com
Enterprise SEO
Google Penalty Solutions
Automation & Search Compliance